Showing posts with label Trinity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trinity. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 11, 2024

Wonder & Mystery | Some Curious Thoughts about the Trinity


Holy Trinity Line Art

When Jesus dives into our world,
the whole Trinity is involved.
Jesus is sent by the Father,
as the "Word become flesh"
in "the power of the Spirit."
Jesus arrives not as a new thing,
but as the eternal Son of God to do a new thing.
Jesus doesn't just point us to the Father; 
He is the action of the Father in our world.
The Father is acting through His Son
and in His Spirit
for the salvation of the world.
+ The Pursuing God

Recently, I have had some friends and family inquire about the wonder and the mystery of the Trinity. Perhaps one with confusion, another with skepticism, another with curiosity; and on such a journey of discovery, all of us experiencing all of the emotions above along the way and more.

I have loved exploring considerations of the Trinity myself, whether throughout the Story of God in all the Scriptures, in Jesus' Church's history including artwork like Rublev's Icon and the "Lakota Trinity," and more. And I recently enjoyed Rev. Dr. Tim Mackie from the Bible Project (ex. "How Is God Both One and Three at the Same Time") discussing the Trinity in the video, "The Trinity, Hermeneutics & Doctrinal Development" (particularly from the 32-minute mark: From Judaism to Trinitarianism until the end).

The post below is meant to provide some brief glimpses into what I've learned and experienced in how the Trinity has opened me up to more of God's beauty and love discovered in how the triune God exists and creates in love apart from me, yet chooses to love me, befriend me, save me, and send me into the world with Emmaus City Church and others to provide glimpses of God's unity in community and community on mission.

 | 1 | 
Wonder & Mystery of the Trinity 
in Love, Worship & Creativity

The Trinity was, and is, a totally self-sufficient community of love and glory. The Trinitarian community is, in a sense, perpetually beholding one another with love and amazement.

Before the world began, there was love.
It flowed
– perfect, complete, and constant –
between the three persons of the Trinity.
This love was an unending appreciation,
a perpetual beholding and rejoicing
in the goodness and perfection
of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.   
We're able to peek through the windows
on that love in the Bible,
where we see the Son worship the Father,
the Father adore and exalt the Son,
and the Spirit being both celebrated
and celebrating the others. 

The word worship comes from the Old English weorthscipe, which combines two words meaning 'ascribe worth.' The Trinity can be said to be always at worship because the three persons of the Godhead perfectly behold the worth and wonder of one another. As hymn writer Fredrick Lehman said:

'Could we with ink the ocean fill,
and were the skies of parchment made,
were every stalk on earth a quill,
and every man a scribe by trade,
to write the love of God above,
would drain the ocean dry.
Nor could the scroll contain the whole,
though stretched from sky to sky.
'
see also
"Love Beyond Telling"

It's out of the overflow
of this endless love
that God created the world.
The whole Trinity is present
at creation's dawn
as the Father speaks,
the Son – who is the Word –
carries out the creative work,
and the Spirit fills the creation
with heavenly presence
(Genesis 1:1-3).


Creation was made out of the overflow of God's own effusive and loving being, a reflection of the way the persons of the Trinity live in harmony, love, and community with one another.

+ Mike Cosper,

At the center of the universe is the spinning dance of the communion of the Father, Son, and Spirit in this selfless, giving, sacrificial orbit of Oneness.

Before even the first shimmer of flaming star danced across space, an all-fulfilled, all-relational triune God, fully complete in the spin of the selfless, giving dance of communion, chose to create a world for the singular purpose of us sharing in His communion, orbiting in His selfless, giving love.

Love is commitment set in motion.

The triune God came for more
than making us right with Him.
He came to make us one with Him.

What the triune God has joined together,
let no way of thinking, dreaming, or living,
tear asunder.

+ Ann Voskamp,

 | 2 | 
Wonder & Mystery of the Trinity
in Embracing Friendship

By virtue of making us like Him, God in creation expanded the circle of friends.

The fundamental truth of friendships
is not that love is limited
but that love is infinite.
We know this because 
the friendship
of the Trinity of the Father, Son, and Spirit
did not generate less love but more love.
Jesus now calls us His friends,
and by saving us, 
He invites us into the dance of the Trinity.
The circle of love is open and expanding.


The nature of true friendships is not to shut the outsider out, it is to draw them in. 
Opening outward is the truest direction of friendship. The circle grows. Here one plus one equals three or even four. The circle is complete, but it is somehow still open. Love defies mathematics and geometry.

In a culture of loneliness and individualism, 
there is no better witness to the Trinity 
than embodying a counterculture 
of real friendship.

If friendship is a practice that reminds us of what the Gospel is, it is also a practice that puts the Gospel on display to the world.

+ Justin Whitmel Earley

 | 3 | 
Wonder & Mystery of the Trinity 
at the Cross of Christ

The atonement drama has only two actors:
the one triune God and us.
And it is God who bears in Himself
the consequences of our sin.

God puts Himself in our place on the cross. He does not "punish somebody else instead." It was God's self-substitution in our place through His own Son. "God was reconciling the world to Himself in Christ" (2 Corinthians 5:19). The Bible sometimes expresses this with balancing statements, and we need to take both side of the balance seriously.

So, for example, we know that the cross was God's will (Acts 2:23). Yes, but Jesus also said, "My food (will) is to do the will of Him who sent Me" (John 4:34, emphasis mine). Isaiah 53:6 says that "the LORD has laid on Him the iniquity of us all." Yes, but Peter also adds, "He Himself bore our sins in His body on the cross" (1 Peter 2:24). John tells us that "God so loved the world that He gave His one and only Son" (John 3:16, emphasis mine). Yes, but Paul adds, "The Son of God ... loved me and gave Himself for me" (Galatians 2:20, emphasis mine). The Father's plan and the Son's actions go together in perfect harmony.

The book The Cross of Christ
by John Stott is a classic.
In one section, he discusses exactly this point:

We have no liberty ...
to imply either that God
compelled Jesus to do what
He was unwilling to do Himself,
or that Jesus was an unwilling victim
of God's harsh justice.
Jesus Christ did indeed bear
the penalty of our sins,
but God was active in
and through Christ doing it,
and Christ was freely playing His part
(e.g. Hebrews 10:5-10). ...
We must never make Christ
the object of God's punishment
or God the object of Christ's persuasion,
for both God and Christ were subjects
not objects, taking the initiative together
to save sinners.
Whatever happened on the cross
in terms of "God-forsakenness"
was voluntarily accepted by both
in the same holy love
which made atonement necessary. ...
The Father did not lay on the Son
an ordeal He was reluctant to bear,
nor did the Son extract
from the Father a salvation
He was reluctant to bestow.
There is no suspicion anywhere
in the New Testament of discord
between the Father and the Son. ...
There was no unwillingness in either.
On the contrary, their wills coincided
in the perfect self-sacrifice of love.

Never separate the Father and the Son in your understanding of the cross. They were as one in Christ's death as they were one in His life.

+ Christopher J.H. Wright,

The Father, Son, and Spirit
remain sovereign
through the event of the cross. 

The Son is sovereign over the grave, 
even as He lies dead in it — 
because the Father and Spirit 
will be faithful to raise Him. 

The Father is sovereign, 
even as His Son marches toward Golgotha — 
because Jesus will not join humanity's rebellion 
and will be faithful unto death. 

The Spirit is sovereign, 
even when entering the grieving 
and groaning of creation to apply
the work of Jesus to our broken world, 
because the Father and Son 
will receive the world He brings.


The hope of the world is God's sovereign love. The Father is, through the Son and in the Spirit, reconciling the world. 

As pastor and author Tim Keller observes:
 
"God did not, then,
inflict pain on someone else,
but rather on the Cross
absorbed the pain, violence, and evil
of the world into Himself.
"


In the words of theologian Adam Johnson,
 
"through Jesus Christ the triune God
brought the reality of sin
into His own proper life,
that He might deal with it
in and through Himself.
"

The cross and resurrection
most powerfully reveal the Trinity
because the Father, Son, and Spirit 
display faithful love to one another 
amid our darkest depths.

The Father, Son, and Spirit
take in our suffering, shattering, and death
in order to overwhelm it
with the life, light, and love
the Father, Son, and Spirit 
share as the one God.

Robert Barron also shares in Light from Light:

One might summarize
a theology of the cross 
as follows. 
The Son of God went to the limits
of alienation from God
so that even as the worst sinner
runs with all her energy 
away from the Father,
she finds herself running
into the arms of the Son.
Here we can see the deep
soteriological implications
of the Trinitarian doctrine.
It is only because God can,
so to speak,
open Himself up,
become other to Himself 
while remaining one in essence,
that He can embrace all of sin,
even the most thoroughgoing rebellion.

God wants to do life with us. We are invited to enter the life of God. In Christ, Peter tells us, we become "participants of the divine nature" (2 Peter 1:3-4). This doesn't mean we become God — we are still creatures, not Creator. But it does mean we participate as creatures in the very life of our Creator: the Spirit of God dwells inside us, binding us in union with Christ, and bringing us through Christ into the embrace of the Father.

This is our salvation: to be indwelt by God within us (the Spirit), united to God before us (the Son), and embraced within the life of God surrounding us (the Father). Our salvation is none other than the very life of God.

Caricature:

The Trinity is an abstract doctrine
with no relevance for today.

Gospel: 

The Trinity changes everything
– the Father, Son, and Spirit
are a holy communion of love
who invite us to participate in eternal life.

+ Joshua Ryan Butler,

 | 4 | 
Wonder & Mystery of the Trinity
in the Mission of God

The first thing we see the Father do in relation to Jesus is love the Son, breathing out His Spirit on Him (see baptism of Jesus, Mark 1:9-11). Doing as His Father does, Jesus breathes out the Spirit on His disciples (see after the resurrection of Jesus, John 20:21-22). In fact, Jesus had already said to them: "As the Father loved Me, so have I loved you" (John 15:9). The Father sends the Son; and doing as His Father does, Jesus thus sends His disciples by the Spirit.

The truth is that God is always on mission:
in love for the other, 
which is why the Father sent His Son
and His Spirit.
It is the outworking of His very nature.
This means that when we go out and share
the knowledge of God's great love
we reflect something very profound
about who God is.
When Jesus sends us, He is allowing us
to share the missional, generous,
outgoing shape of God's own life.

The Spirit-caused enjoyment of the fellowship, the increasing love for the Father and the Son: it turns us to share God's outgoing love for the world. We become like what we worship. The Spirit shares the triune life of God by bringing God's children into the mutual delight of the Father and the Son — and there we become like our God: fruitful and life-giving.

+ Michael Reeves,

The only way to be the greatest in Christ's Kingdom is to be the last, to have the least left in your own ego and self-will, to pour out your whole self for others as He did for you.

It is a very strange Kingdom that this King invites us into, because it is the Kingdom of God, and God is very strange.

God is love; God is agape,
and that means that God 
is the total gift of self
from each of the the three persons
of the Trinity to each of the other two.

In inviting us into His Kingdom of agape,
Jesus is inviting us into theosis,
which means not imitation 
but participation,
the sharing in the very life of God,
who is the source of everything real
and true and good and beautiful
and joyful.

This truth about God is also a truth
about us because we were designed
and created in God's image.
We were designed to only run
on the fuel that God runs on,
to live only with God's life.
That's why we get joy only
by giving joy;
we find ourselves only
by losing ourselves;
we live only by dying to our
natural selfishness.
It's not an ideal; it's a fact.
It's what we are,
what we are made for.

+ Dr. Peter Kreeft,

 | 5 | 
Wonder & Mystery of the Trinity 
in Being Jesus' Church

The intention of Jesus' Church is to be a "community for the community": a multi-generational, life-transforming, unwaveringly Christ-centered community of people who, together, worship the Triune God, proclaim and demonstrate the Good News of God,
and provide every person: 

a people to belong to in the family of God,
a people to grow with in Jesus Christ,
and a people to serve alongside
by the leading and power of the Holy Spirit.

Since the very essence of the Trinity
is the shared, interrelated communion of love
between Father, Son, and Holy Spirit,
then the "essence" of the Church
reflecting the Trinity is
the unity of its members' love for one another
(John 13:34-35).
For if "God is what God is in interrelatedness,"
then human transformation is
both dependent upon and realized in
a similar interrelatedness.

While God is by nature a communion of Father, Son, and Spirit, human persons enter into covenantal commitment to effect the kind of interdependence necessary for transformation (ex. baptismal vows offered as a community). And as the "fruit of the Spirit" (Gal. 5:22-26) attests, relational maturity is virtually indistinguishable from spiritual maturity, and the spirituality of a community is defined by the quality of the relationships formed. As we do so, we demonstrate a quality of living that the world is yearning for and through which
humans have been created to thrive.

+ Tod Bolsinger

 | Bonus | 
Wonder & Mystery of the Trinity 
in Oneness, Unity & Peace

Richard of St. Victor (1100s A.D.) shared that if God were just one person, God could not be intrinsically loving, since for all eternity before creation, God would have had nobody to love. If there were two persons, Richard went on, God might be loving, but in an excluding, ungenerous way. After all, when two persons love each other, they can be so infatuated with each other that they simply ignore everyone else — and a God like that would be very far from good news. But when the love between two persons is happy, healthy and secure, they rejoice to share it. Just so it is with God, said Richard. Being perfectly loving, from all eternity the Father and the Son have delighted to share love and joy with and through the Spirit.

It is not then that God becomes sharing;
being triune, God is a sharing God,
a God who loves to include.
Indeed, that is why God will go on to create.
His love is not for keeping but for spreading.

Created male and female, in the image of God, and with many other good differences between us, we come together valuing the way the triune God has made us each unique.

Oneness for the triune God means unity.
As the Father is absolutely one with His Son,
and yet is not His Son,
so Jesus prays that believers might be one,
but not that they might all be the same.

There are different kinds of gifts,
but the same Spirit. ...
If the whole body were an eye,
where would the sense of hearing be?
If the whole body were an ear,
where would the sense of smell be?
But in fact God has arranged the parts
in the body, every one of them,
just as He wanted them to be.
If they were all one part,
where would the body be?
As it is, there are many parts,
but one body.
(1 Corinthians 12:4, 17-20).

So it is not just that the Father, Son and Spirit call us into fellowship; God shares heavenly harmony that there might be harmony on earth, that people of different genders, languages, hobbies, and gifts might be one voice, we might cry: "Salvation belongs to our God, who sits on the throne, and to the Lamb" (Revelation 7:10).

And that is what the family of God — by its very existence — makes known to the world: that the God of harmony is the hope for world peace; that He can and will unite enemies, rivals and strangers into one loving family under His fatherly care.

+ Michael Reeves,

Trinity Knot Scripture: Ephesians 4:3-6

4th Century Church 
Adapted by New Life, 
2022 A.D.

How lovely all creation shines,
How glorious from sky to sea.
All beauty is a blazing sign
To God the Everlasting.

Glory to the Father, 
Glory to the Son,
Glory to the Holy Spirit.
As it was in the beginning, 
As it is right now,
And will be forever,
World without end. 
Amen.

The glory of Almighty God,
The centerpiece of all that is.
The selflessness of triune love,
Demands our highest worship.
(Chorus)

Amen, amen, amen,
World without end, 
Amen.

When we behold the radiant Son,
The shadowlands will fade away.
At last the One who is to come
Will rule the new creation.
He’ll rule the new creation.
(Chorus)

The Father, Son, and Holy Spirit
are certainly not modifications 
of the substance of "God,"
for that would compromise
the divine simplicity;
and yet they are not separate beings,
for that would result in tri-theism.
compromising the divine unity.
They are, we are forced to say, 
"pure" relations subsisting as relations.
Thus, the Father is Father only in and as
a relation to the Son;
the Son is Son only in and as 
a relation to the Father;
and the Spirit is Spirit only in and as
a relation to the Father and the Son.
All three persons, 
since they share the 
singular divine essence, 
are utterly simple in their 
manner of existing.
Yet, these dynamics do indeed indicate
that something like giving (or offering)
and receiving,
breathing in and breathing out,
obtains within God.

+ Robert Barron 
in reference to 
St. Augustine's, St. Anselm's 
and St. Thomas Aquinas' 
thoughts on the Trinity
shared in Light from Light

Other Reading Recs:

Next post: 


With presence and peace in Christ,

Rev. Mike “Sully” Sullivan

Email Pastor Mike | Website | Visit Us | Support Us | Facebook Us


Wednesday, October 26, 2022

CN Special: Rublev's Icon | A Window into the Heart of God


Rublev's Icon featured in The Pursuing God by Joshua Ryan Butler


God doesn't create us because he needs us; he creates us because he wants us. God is not just being; God is Being, the ground of our existence. The Trinity creates the world in divine freedom, not to fill a need within but from an overflow of divine life, light, and love. God is not trying to get something from us; God is giving God to us. Divine love gives birth to creation. In the words of C.S. Lewis, "in God there is no hunger that needs to be filled, only plenteousness that desires to give." We were created by the spreading goodness of God, and exist for this goodness — to live and subsist enfolded within the overwhelming, enveloping love of God. God is generous goodness. + Joshua Ryan Butler, The Pursuing God


In light of wonder and abundance being themes I think God has wanted me to focus on in 2022, I received a beautiful invitation in a time of prayer with others among Emmaus City Church to return this week to one of my favorite books of the past decade, The Pursuing God by Joshua Ryan Butler. 

Both of Butler's books, The Skeletons in God's Closet and The Pursuing God, are in my Top 20 books that I've read in the past 10 years, and today I wanted to share his reflection on Rublev's icon, an image of invitation that has shaped the holy imagination of Orthodox, Catholic, and Protestant followers of Jesus for centuries. If you've never "read" a visual icon before, some things to notice before reading Butler's verbal reflection are: 

the colors, 
the posture of the figures, 
the walking staffs, 
the mountain, the tree, and the home, 
and the chalice.

But before I share this excerpt from The Pursuing God, here is a brief word from Butler for those who are unfamiliar with the history of icons and/or concerned about them in some form or fashion:

A word about icons: some people worry about "worshipping" them, but icons don't depict God directly. They depict scenes and characters from Scripture and are intended to be viewed more like a window than a painting, meant not so much to be looked at, but through, using color, symbolism, and imagery to give us a glimpse into the story of the gospel and the heart of God. Especially in times when most people were illiterate, icons were able to communicate truths visually about God on a broad and popular level that was easy to understand and remember.


Rublev's Icon | A Colorful Window into the Heart of God, the Trinity

Rublev's icon comes from a scene in Genesis 18, where Abraham shares a meal with three angelic visitors. In the passage, we eventually learn that Abraham is actually having a meal with God, and these visitors give him the promise of a son through whom God will save the world. 

Rublev depicts this meal scene, and uses it as a window into the life of the Trinity. Let's start with a look at their colors.  
1) The Spirit (on the right) is clothed in blue like the skies above and green like the grass below. The significance? The Spirit moves through heaven and earth, sustaining all things — the atmosphere we breathe and the ground beneath our feet — and bringing life to the world. All things hold together in the Spirit; were God's presence to completely depart, creation would fall apart. 
2) The Son (in the middle) wears reddish brown like earthen clay, and blue like the heights of the sky we look up to. This speaks to Jesus bearing flesh and bone, being fully united with our humanity and the earth from which we are made (the red), yet fully divine, bearing all the transcendence of heaven above (the blue). Jesus unites divinity and humanity in his very person, reconciling heaven and earth. And Jesus wears a gold sash over his shoulder, sign of his royal authority that reminds us, "the government will be upon His shoulder." The Son of heaven is the King of earth, the desire of the nations, and the hope of the world. 
3) The Father (on the left) appears to wear all colors. The garment's fabric seems almost transparent, changing with the light. A patch of blue underneath reminds us of his transcendent divinity as our heavenly Father, yet we are struck more by the radiance of his clothing. God is beyond description, yet fills the universe through his Son and Spirit, fulfilling all things in himself. 
4) Finally, notice the radiance around their faces and how everything that touches them is gold: their seats, wings, and chalice. God's presence communicates value. All things are made precious, perfect, and holy in their midst. It is not that the Trinity has valuable things; rather, things become valuable in their midst. 
The Father, Son, and Spirit shine brightly in their light, life, and love, bathing all who soak in their presence with the radiance of their glorious goodness.

Rublev's Icon | A Posture of Holy Love

Notice their posture. This is perhaps the most significant feature of the icon. Each person is bent outward away from himself, his gaze arched toward the others in love. The position of their hands, the openness of their bodies, the look on their faces, all communicate a giving outward and receiving from others.

The Father, Son, and Spirit are not grasping for power and attention from one another, but rather giving glory and attention to each other. This speaks to a major theme in Jesus' teaching: that the Father seeks to glorify the Son, the Son seeks to glorify the Father, and the Spirit brings glory to them both. Rather than seeking to build their own platform against one another, they lift up one another. In Jesus' longest recorded prayer (John 17), the main theme is the Father, Son, and Spirit glorifying one another in the love they've had from before the creation of the world.

How are the Father, Son, and Spirit one God? The church has used a fancy Greek word, perichoresis, to explore this. It means "mutual indwelling" and comes from the image of a circle dance — combining the words peri ("around") and chorein ("make room for") — think of three dances moving "around" one another and "making room for" one another. In their rapid, harmonious movement, it can be hard to tell where one stops and the other begins.

The Father, Son, and Spirit mutually indwell one another. Jesus declares, "I am in the Father and the Father is in me" (John 14:10-11); the Father actually indwells Jesus' identity, and vice versa. Their identities are intertwined, overflowing into one another. Jesus even goes so far as the say, "If you've seen me, you've seen the Father (John 14:9)." We not only look at Jesus, but through Jesus, to encounter the heart of the Father. Jesus is like a powerful icon through whom we see the face of God.

The Father, Son, and the Spirit define themselves in relation to one another. Without the Son, the Father would not be a father. Without the Father, the Son would not be a son. Without them both, the Spirit would not be their spirit. The Father, Son, and Spirit are God. As you look at the actions of Jesus, you're actually seeing the Father's movement in his world, in the power of their Spirit. As if this indwelling couldn't get pushed any further, Jesus tops the cake, saying, "I and the Father are one" (John 10:30). The Father and Son are, in their Spirit, an external communion of holy love. They are bound up in, with, and for one another. God is inherently relational.


Rublev's Icon | Walking Staffs, a Mountain, Tree, and Home

God enters the journey with us. 
Each of three figures in Rublev's icon carries a walking staff, a sign that God travels down our dusty roads to find us and bring us home. What does this journey home look like? In the background landscape, behind the Father, Son, and Spirit, are a mountain, a tree, and a house. Each depicts a part of our journey into the heart of God. 
The mountain is behind the Spirit. The Spirit of God finds us in the rocky, distant places, and guides us along paths that may be steep and difficult, but ultimately brings us through these treacherous trails to a high place, the "mountaintop experience," where heaven and earth meet. As the Spirit guides us up the trail, the mountain is arched toward Jesus: the Spirit's goal is to lead us to Jesus. 
Jesus sits before a tree, which spreads its shade to offer rest and refreshment from the heat of the sun and the difficult journey. We are reminded of the Tree of Life in Eden, where we were created to receive life in union with God, and of the cross, where Jesus transforms our death-dealing curse on that forsaken tree into life-giving power through his resurrection, reestablishing the Tree of Life and breathing the winds of Eden back into creation. Jesus is the Tree of Life who replants the garden of God. The tree is also, like the mountain, bent to the left, toward that Father: Jesus brings us home to the Father. 
Notice how the Father's house has a tower, rising high above everything else, giving the Father a sovereign view of the whole land below. Its door and upper window are open, facing outward toward the world. In the words of one observer, our Father's home is "the goal of our journey, the beginning and end of our lives ... Its door is always open, it has a tower, and its window is always open so that the Father can incessantly scan the roads for a glimpse of a returning prodigal." 
Our heavenly Father's posture is one of open embrace, inviting us into life with him. The Father pursues us through his Son, in their Spirit, with the goal to bring us home.

Rublev's Icon | Through the Son, In the Spirit, a Personal Union

The icon is meant to be read from left to right: from the Father, through the Son, to the Spirit. The early church held that God always acts through his Son and in his Spirit. Irenaeus, one of the earliest church fathers, described Jesus and the Holy Ghost as the "two hands" of God, always present in all his works. So, for example, at creation God spoke the world into existence through his Word (saying, "Let there be!") and in his Spirit ("hovering over the waters").

Jesus is this Word through whom the universe was spoken into existence, the very Voice of God, and the Holy Spirit is this Spirit in whom the world has come to be, the very Breath of God, now indwelling our hearts. Similarly, throughout the Old Testament, the "word of the LORD" and "Spirit of God" come to prophets, priests, and kings, bringing God's action to bear in the world. The church has used a Latin phrase for this: opera ad extra indivisa. It means all of God's actions in the world, or operations on the outside (opera ad extra) of his life as God, are works of the Father, Son, and Spirit together, undivided or indivisible (indivisa) as the whole Trinity. So, for example, the Father does not create the world alone, or the Son redeem by himself, or the Spirit sanctify as a solo project. 

The whole Trinity, all three persons, are involved together in everything they do. This means when Jesus dives into our world, the whole Trinity is involved. Jesus is sent by the Father, as the "Word become flesh" in "the power of the Spirit." Jesus arrives not as a new thing, but as the eternal Son of God to do a new thing. Jesus doesn't just point us to the Father; he is the action of the Father in our world. The Father is acting through his Son and in his Spirit for the salvation of the world. Together, they're taking on the sin, destruction, and decay we've unleashed in order to restore their masterpiece. The cross doesn't happen to the Trinity; the Trinity happens to the cross. The cross is a triune act.

Rublev's Icon | The Chalice of the Eucharist

At the center of Rublev's icon, on the table, is a chalice. It is a picture of Christ's sacrifice for us, the Eucharist of his body broken and blood shed to bring us home. Inside the chalice is a slain animal. In the Abraham story of Genesis 18, a "choice, tender calf" was chosen for the meal. In the gospel, Jesus is "the Lamb, who was slain," elected from before creation to atone for sin and restore us to the table.

The chalice belongs not only to Jesus, however, but to the Trinity as a whole. The cup stands at the center of their table, inviting us into their fellowship. The chalice embodies the Father's sacrificial self-giving, in and through his Son and Spirit, to bring us into communion with the very life of God.

The table upon which the chalice sits is actually an altar. If you look at the base of the altar, you will see a little square opening. This is the space where, in the Russian Orthodox tradition, pictures of the saints are kept. The significance? We are welcomed to the meal, invited through Christ's sacrifice into fellowship with God. 

Notice how the Father, Son, and Spirit create space for us to enter. If you think of the icon as a clock, they are at the 9:00, 12:00, and 3:00 positions. But space is opened up in the 6:00 position, at the front of the icon, inviting us as the viewer to enter the circle of divine hospitality and join in the feast. God wants to do life with us. We are invited to enter the life of God. In Christ, Peter tells us, we become "participants of the divine nature" (2 Peter 1:3-4). This doesn't mean we become God — we are still creatures, not Creator. But it does mean we participate as creatures in the very life of our Creator: the Spirit of God dwells inside us, binding us in union with Christ, and bringing us through Christ into the embrace of the Father. The Spirit surrounds and indwells us as the bride, lifting the veil before our eyes so that we see Christ, our Groom, revealed before us, and through our union with Christ, we enter the household of the Father, being surrounded and indwelt by the very life of God. 
This is our salvation: to be indwelt by God within us (the Spirit), united to God before us (the Son), and embraced within the life of God surrounding us (the Father). Our salvation is none other than the very life of God. 


+ Joshua Ryan Butler, Chapter 25: Communion of Love and Chapter 26: The Journey Home in The Pursuing God, excerpts from pgs. 186-196

Here are links to other recent City Notes (CN) books:

With presence, peace, and many prayerful blessings,

Rev. Mike “Sully” Sullivan

Thursday, May 7, 2020

The Common Rule | Embrace + Resist Weekly: Christ Fills


" ... The question 'Is there anything you aren't telling me?' gets at the heart of friendship, because friendship is being known by someone else and loved anyway. ... " + The Common Rule: Habits of Purpose for an Age of Distraction


This is the final post of 3 reflecting on how to receive our days and weeks as gifts and blessings to share with others (the 1st and 2nd can be found here: The Common Rule: Discovering the Freedom of Limitations + Embrace + Resist Daily: Habits of Light & Presence Is Life). We'll continue with what we can embrace weekly and how this helps us resist in order to love well.

"Embrace + Resist Weekly in Order to Love Well" excerpts adapted from Justin Whitmel Earley's The Common Rule: Habits of Purpose in an Age of Distraction


Embrace is a reminder that there is much good in the world God made. God's presence  not his absence  is the primary foundation of the world. That we need each other  not that we harm each other — is the primary truth of being human. In the habits of embrace, we try to train our bodies and our hearts to love God as he actually is and to turn to our neighbor as we were made to do. The habits of embrace are: sabbath, prayer, meals, and conversation.

Resistance is when we acknowledge that evil and suffering are very real, though they aren't how the world was made to be. Our world is full of a thousand invisible habits of fear, anger, anxiety, and envy that we unconsciously and consciously adopt. Should we do nothing, we will be taught to love the very things that tear us apart. So we must take up the fight, open our eyes to the way media form us in fear and hate, the way screens form us in absence, and see the way excess and laziness train us to love ourselves above all else. But remember that resistance has purpose: love. The habits of resistance aren't supposed to shield you from the world but to turn you toward it. They aren't so you can feel good about what you've done for you. They exist so you can feel peace about what God has done for you. The habits of resistance are: fasting, Scripture before phone, phone off, and curate media.

Embrace Weekly Habit 1: Ways to Start the Weekly Habit of One Hour of Conversation with a Friend

Without communication, there can be no community. ... That is why conversation, discussion or talk is the most important form of speaking or listening. + Mortimer J. Adler

Something much more personal floated about the room. It was an unspoken question: Is there anything you aren't telling me? That is the question that goes either unasked or unanswered in so many lives that collapse. Often, if honestly asked and honestly answered, this question can turn whole lives around. Secrets feed off going untold, and darkness exists only where there is no light. ... Vulnerability and time turn people who have a relationship into people who have a friendship. That's what friendship is: vulnerability across time. The practice of conversation is the basis of friendship because it's in conversation that we become exposed to each other. ... There's nothing more terrifying and redemptive than removing the fig leaf and telling who you are to a friend. It's terrifying because we are never who we wish we were. It's redemptive because that's at the core of enacting the gospel in communal life. Friendships embody the power of the gospel in a unique way, because in friendship we live out the truth of the gospel to each other. What is the gospel besides that Jesus knows how broken we are and sticks around to love us anyway? What is a friend except someone who knows how broken we are yet sticks around to love us anyway?

The fundamental truth of friendships is not that love is limited but that love is infinite. We know this because the friendship of the Trinity of the Father, Son, and Spirit did not generate less love but more love. By virtue of making us like him, God in creation expanded the circle of friends. Jesus now calls us his friends, and by saving us, he invites us into the dance of the Trinity. The circle of love is open and expanding. The nature of true friendships is not to shut the outsider out, it is to draw them in. ... Opening outward is the truest direction of friendship. The circle grows. Here one plus one equals three or even four. The circle is complete, but it is somehow still open. Love defies mathematics and geometry. If friendship is a practice that reminds us of what the gospel is, it is also a practice that puts the gospel on display to the world. In a culture of loneliness and individualism, there is no better witness to the Trinity than embodying a counterculture of real friendship.

Standing meetingTry setting up a standing time with a friend  such as every Thursday evening or every Friday morning  when you always get together. Don't be discouraged by the fact that sometimes you have to miss; be encouraged by the fact that the rule is getting together, and the exception is missing it sometimes.

On telling secrets. Tell your secrets. Do it tonight. It will change your life and will probably inspire your friends to tell theirs too. There's no bigger catalyst for deep relationships than telling your secrets.

The power of good questions. Often great conversations come from someone who has mastered the art of good questions.

Resist Weekly Habit 1: Ways to Start the Weekly Habit to Curate Media to Four Hours

Stories as Formation

We become the stories we consume. The Latin root of the word decide  cise or cide — is to "cut off" or "kill." The idea is that to choose anything means to kill off other options you might have otherwise chosen. That day I realized that by choosing one story, I would have to cut off other stories. I had to choose one thing at the expense of many, many other things. I would have to choose carefully. I would have to curate my stories (see Story of God: Creation, Crisis, Covenant, Christ, Church, (New) Creation) 
Creation: Our story begins with the creation of the world. Eden is the opening scene of a movie in which everything is the way it's supposed to be.  
Crisis: And then we're hooked by tragedy: the fall of humanity and the separation of humans from God. Then there's the chase, the conflict.
Covenant: How will God rescue his people? He shows his love for them in the Old Testament's dramatic scenes of romance, in tracking them down through deserts, and saving them from war. And then the plot thickens.
Christ: Just when things couldn't get worse, we find out that God will not just come for his people; he will become his people. Jesus is the archetypal hero who comes in to save the world. But he won't save the world by fighting; he will save it by dying. 
Church: The gospel is tragedy: Humanity will be saved, but God has to die. But there is a twist. The resurrection defies all expectations. Evil is defeated, and good will reign.
(New) Creation: God will win after all, and love will prevail. There is a new time coming, and the kingdom will have no end. 
The gospel moves  in the words of Presbyterian pastor and author Frederick Buechner  from tragedy, to comedy, to fairy tale. The point is this: We don't just watch stories, we live in one. We are characters in the most epic narrative of all time, and it is real. It is a story unfolding in actual time, and the stories we watch are all trying to explain to us what this real story is about. They help us figure out how to live in our own story. When the Methodist theologian Stanley Hauerwas argued that story is "the necessary grammar of Christian convictions," he was saying that the Bible isn't primarily a moral message on what is right and wrong; it's a story of how God is saving us. We can't understand morality from situation to situation unless we first understand the story we're in, who the hero is, how we are being rescued, and from what. 
In On Moral Fiction, John Gardner wrote that a good story beats back the chaos of the world. A good story shows us that there is some kind of world with beginnings and endings, where things happen  and happen for a reason. Stories convince us that things are, after all, going somewhere. That's why stories more than any ethics lecture shape our idea of what the good life is, where the world is going, and what it means to be human. They tell us what is beautiful, what is just, and how we should live with each other. This is why we don't just watch stories. We become them.

Now, we don't choose our stories nearly as much as they choose us. Should we do nothing, someone else's stories will curate our lives for us. If we don't cut off their options; they will cut off our options. ... The good life doesn't come from the ability to choose anything and everything; the good life comes from the ability to choose good things by setting limits. Limits are where freedom is found. We don't need unlimited choices; that actually limits our ability to choose well. We need a limit on our choices, which actually empowers us to choose well. By limiting stories to a certain number of hours in a week, you introduce the ability to choose them well. Curation implies a sense of the good. An art gallery has limited space on the wall, so its curator creates shows to make the best use of that space according to a vision for good art. I suggest we have a vision for good stories, and we curate accordingly. We could start with curating for beauty, justice, and community.

Stories matter so much that we must handle them with the utmost care. Resisting the constant stream of addictive media with an hour limit means we are forced to curate what we watch. Curating stories means that we seek stories that uphold beauty, that teach us to love justice, and that turn us to community.

A time audit. Track your media watching for a week, and then set an hour goal for the next week that is four hours, or some other reasonable number you feel comfortable with.

Make great lists of great stories. Keep a running list of great movies, shows, or podcasts to listen to. One of the best ways to curate stories well is to encounter great stories. They change us. They both satisfy us and make us hungry for more great stories. Often novels or movies that have stood the test of time are the best places to start. Notice also that the written form resists addiction because of the time you have to put into it. Balance your media by also reading a great novel or biography.

Curate with others. I choose better when I choose in public spaces. For that reason, I keep a program on my computer that shares my entire internet history with a couple other close friends. The point here is to figure out what helps you curate the best and to notice that usually we curate worse when we curate in private.

Resist Daily Habit 2: Ways to Start the Weekly Habit to Fast from Something for 24 Hours 

Eating Away Our Emptiness

In a world of suffering and death, one of our greatest temptations is to rehearse the fall again and again through food. We eat to try to fill our emptiness. This is why fasting is mentioned so often in the Bible. Fasting is a way to resist the original sin of trying to eat our way to happiness and to force ourselves to look to God for our fullness. In that sense, to fast is to lean into the truth of the world: we are empty without God. "Man does not live by bread alone" (Deuteronomy 8:3).

In fasting, what begins with experiencing the emptiness of our stomach ends in experiencing the emptiness of the world. In the Bible, fasting is not just to reveal and clarify our own need for God. It is to lean into the suffering of the world itself and to long for God to redeem it. This is why the Israelites during the time of Esther fasted; they knew the brokenness and injustice of the throne they lived under, and they longed for God to redeem it.

This is partly why Jesus fasted before he began his ministry. He was sent to undo the fall, and his forty-day fast was an act of longing for the world to be restored by his ministry to come. He emptied himself in a bodily prayer for the world's fullness. In this way, fasting tracks the plotline of all things. We must be emptied in order to be filled. Christ denied his body so we could partake of his body. The weekly habit of fasting, then, is a way to lean into both the emptiness of the world as it is and prayer for the coming fullness of the world as it will be. The world doesn't end in fasting, of course, but in a feast. Above all, we fast because we long for the wedding supper of the Lamb.

Christ in the Emptiness

Even when the prayers aren't answered (or at least in the way we thought they could or should be during fasting), in the space that fasting opens up, we find something else: Christ. He is the one who can and will fix all of this, and the one we are to be with while we make an effort to do the same.

In emptying ourselves, we practice becoming like Christ, who emptied himself. We practice sharing in his sufferings. It isn't on the mountains of triumph and victory but in the valleys of sorrow and loss that he waits for us. ... It is possible to be a people who avoid our exile within America and constantly lean into assimilation into our culture. We can easily forget that the place of friction, persecution, minority suffering, wilderness, emptiness, and hunger  that is the place where Jesus is. Fasting, as a practice, is a way to enter into Jesus' life. He was a homeless, hungry minority. He was a refugee and an outcast. He was actually  not just metaphorically  poor. He lived among violence. He died violently. To follow Jesus is not just to believe in his life; it is also to follow him into his lifestyle. And that idea runs hard against my usual expectations of being American. It's hard to be poor in a land of plenty, and it's hard to be hungry in a land of sugar. It's hard to be empathetic in a land where we hide the poor on the other side of the interstate. But fasting is a habit of breaking that comfort in order to seek true comfort instead. We continue to fast because that's where we find Jesus  right on the fault line of the beautiful and the broken. The miracles we see in fasting are amazing. And the brokenness we enter into in fasting is unbearable. This is, I suppose, why the practice of fasting is a beautiful and painful reminder of a good world cracked by the fall. Cultivating the habit of fasting as a way of life means cultivating an understanding of why beauty and brokenness intertwine in the present world. I know of no other way of life that can both acknowledge all that the Lord has done and still yearn for all that we desperately long for him to do.

Sundown to sundown. My preferred fast begins at sundown on a Thursday and ends with a communal breaking of the fast at sundown on a Friday. This is a great way to do twenty-four-hour communal fast with friends. Also, usually just skipping meals doesn't lead to prayer. I find that I need to take walks instead of eating to actually pray.

Start with a mealIf fasting intimidates you, a great place to start is just skipping a meal  maybe lunch  and replacing it with prayer. If you do it with family, skip your family meal so you can pray together. 

Communal fastingI find fasting far rich in community  not to mention it's so hard to muster the discipline when it's just me doing it. Consider having a text or email chain going among people who are fasting so you can share encouragements and prayers. Also consider doing an initial prayer time together and/or breaking the fast together.

Multiple days. I've also had difficult times where fasting for multiple days was the way to repentance. There's something unique about the state the body and soul enters into on longer fasts, and I would recommend working toward them as an occasional practice.

Embrace Daily Habit 2: Ways to Start the Weekly Habit of Sabbath

The Restless Soul

This is why we live in a culture that can't accept sabbath; we do not believe that work is from God and for our neighbor. Instead we believe that work is from us and for us. It's something we pursue to become who we want to become.

Our careers define us. This is the American dream. We can work our way to significance. This is what we're doing when we prove our busyness to ourselves and each other; we're trying to show that we matter, that the world wants us, that the world depends on us. But the gospel wants to put that to rest. We don't have to work like that because Jesus has done that work for us. And he has finished it. The book of Hebrews tells us that God has entered into his eternal rest, which is another way of saying that God has entered his full sabbath, because his work is done. This is because God has not only finished the work of creation, now in Jesus he has finished the work of redemption too.

When the project went wrong because of our sin, God came in to fix it in the form of a baby. When Jesus came to live and die among us, he came to finish the work once and for all. This is why, in his final words on the cross, Jesus cries out, "It is finished!" What is finished? The work of salvation. In his death and resurrection, Jesus has done everything needed to unite us back to the God who loves us. There is not a single thing to add. But there is everything to receive. The rest beneath the rest is the knowledge that in Jesus all work is finished. This is why Augustine wrote, "My soul is restless until it finds rest in thee." When that's true, we can finally take a day off. We can finally take a nap or stare at a cloud or have a long dinner with friends. "It is finished" is the lullaby of all things, our restless hearts included.

I think of the person of Jesus. We are all looking for someone we trust to look us in the eye and tell us we've done enough, that it's okay to stop. This is the good news of the gospel. ... Here's the truth: we are messed up beyond belief, but loved beyond belief, and that is the one thing worthy of our belief.

If you've lived your life believing that you can earn your worth, that you can earn your salvation by outweighing the bad with the good, that you can justify your place in this world through the money you earn or status you achieve  come and rest! Come and sabbath with Jesus. Here there is peace that no amount of effort can buy: he came to you first. He lived the good life we are all trying to live. He did it all. He sacrificed everything. He always said the right thing. He always knew what to do and where to go. And where did it get him? It got him killed. People hated him. They stripped him naked and killed him. He lived the light of life we're all trying to live, and he was answered with death. But it was all for love. It was all for you! He stayed up all night in the garden of Gethsemane so you could sleep. He finished his work on the cross so you could rest. He let the world break him so it doesn't have to break you. He rose from the grave so all your aspirations won't end in the grave. ... Love has first come to us. Anything and everything else we do comes after. All these things are simply a response to this astounding love.

Pick a 24-hour period

Doing and not doingWrite down three things to do and three things you want to avoid. 

Electronic sabbaths. I recommend doing a month of Sabbaths with no screens at all to get a real sense of what it's like.

On Failure and Beauty

It was if someone had laid out a trip wire. I was running full speed through this psalm when I was suddenly cut off at the knees and went sprawling face first onto this line: "One thing I will seek after, to behold the beauty of the Lord" (Psalm 27:4, paraphrase). ... Sin means that my heart curves inward, but the words of Scripture had cracked me open.

Apparently nothing else I ever said about the Common Rule habits was as helpful as talking about failure  because failure is where we live. This was the morning I realized that failure is not the enemy of formation; it is the liturgy of formation. How we deal with failure says volumes about who we really believe we are. Who we really believe God is. When we trip on failure, do we fall into ourselves? Or do we fall into grace? Failure is the path; beauty is the destination. We walk toward beauty on the path of failure. Which is to say that formation occurs at the interplay of failure and beauty. No habits can be pursued for the purpose of success or productivity or a new and better you. They must be done for the vision of beauty. If the goal is self-help, failure will destroy you. But if the goal is beauty, failure makes that goal shine all the more brightly. ... Any process of curating a beautiful life will be laced with failure. That's what process means: learning as you go. But that's not an impediment to a beautiful life; it's the way to it. ... This is the ethic of the search for beauty, which is the only true worship. 
Like the woman pouring perfume on Jesus' feet ... You'll try anything, because you're lost in the one you love.
Here are links to previous City Notes books:

Christ is all,


Rev. Mike “Sully” Sullivan

Email Pastor Mike | Website | Visit Us | Support Us | Facebook Us